Quick Cozies: Uncovering The Clues for Our Top 5 Cozy Mystery Short Stories!

Are you looking for a quick escape into a cozy mystery? Look no further than our list of the top 5 cozy mystery short stories! Get ready to curl up with a cup of tea and your favorite detective!

Wynn Kelly

5/14/20237 min read

Are you ready to get cozy with a good mystery? If you're in the mood for some thrilling short stories, you've come to the right place. We’ve rounded up our top five cozy mystery short stories that will keep you on the edge of your seat.

From an amateur detective solving a murder in a small town to friends deciphering a strange code, these stories will keep you guessing until the very end. Each one is packed with suspense and intrigue, making them perfect for a cozy night in.

These stories are full of twists and turns, so you’ll never know what’s coming next. Plus, their short length makes them perfect for a quick read. If you’re looking for a way to escape into a different world for a few hours, these stories will do the trick.

So get cozy and get ready to be surprised by our top five cozy mystery short stories. With their intriguing plots and unexpected twists, they’ll keep you entertained until the very last page. Get ready to be swept away on an adventure into the unknown!


How We Choose The Best Mystery

When you're looking for a good mystery to get lost in, why not try something short? Cozy mysteries are the perfect way to escape into a thrilling story without having to commit too much time.

But with so many cozy mysteries out there, it can be hard to know which ones will keep you hooked until the end. The GKB Team’s top picks are based on reader experiences and verified customer reviews on Amazon to find the best cozy mystery short stories for you. We've done all the hard work so that you can easily find and purchase the perfect mystery for your reading pleasure.

So don't waste your time trying to figure out which story is worth investing in – our top 5 cozy mystery short stories have been chosen for their captivating plots, intriguing characters, and unexpected twists! Check them out today and get ready for some serious page-turning!

Agnes and the Twisted Truth

Here's The Why:

Raven Hill Farm Mysteries Agnes and the Twisted Truth is a captivating novel that will have your heart racing! Set in the beautiful west of Ireland, this thrilling mystery follows Quinn and Fiona as they uncover the truth behind a murder in the small town of Ballyfrannen. With twists and turns that will surprise you at every corner, Agnes and the Twisted Truth is an immersive and engaging read that will leave you wanting more.

Raven Hill Farm Mysteries Agnes and the Twisted Truth is the perfect book for any fan of thrilling mysteries. It is full of unexpected twists and turns that will keep you guessing until the very end. Quinn and Fiona are two Americans who moved to a small farm in Ireland and find themselves in the middle of the mystery. With themes of justice, morality, and mental illness, Agnes and the Twisted Truth is sure to entertain and educate. If you are looking for a thrilling and fast-paced read, this is the book for you!

Witchdependence Day

Here's The Why:

Witchdependence Day is the perfect book for any fan of the Winchester Witches series! Marcus Richmond may be the quiet one, but don't let his soft-spoken demeanor fool you. When something strange is going on in Hemlock Cove, Marcus is determined to get to the bottom of it. He's got his hands full with renovations at his stable, plans for the future with a certain feisty witch, and a mysterious FBI agent who is investigating the strange goings-on. It's the perfect holiday weekend read and you'll get to experience the Fourth of July celebrations in Hemlock Cove while solving a mystery. Plus, you can get to know Aunt Tillie better as she takes matters into her own hands when no one is looking.

Witchdependence Day is an exciting mystery featuring a strong and determined protagonist, Marcus Richmond. Marcus knows what he wants and he's willing to go to any lengths to get it. This book is part of the popular Winchester Witches series, making it perfect for fans of the series. It's a great read for teens and adults alike, and it's sure to keep you entertained and on the edge of your seat until the end. So why wait? Pick up Witchdependence Day today and enjoy the Fourth of July celebrations in Hemlock Cove!


Baked Betrayal

Here's The Why:

Experience the thrill of a page-turning mystery novel with Dogwood Donuts owner and amateur sleuth, Maggie Mission, in Baked Betrayal! This Culinary Cozy Mystery features a romantic honeymoon gone wrong as Maggie and her husband Brett head to the Smoky Mountains, only to be cut off from the rest of the world due to a major storm and then discover a body in a neighboring cabin. As Maggie and Brett get caught up in a web of intrigue, they must figure out who is telling the truth and uncover the secrets and lies before it’s too late. With an interesting plot, captivating characters, and delicious recipes, Baked Betrayal is sure to keep you guessing until the end.

If you love cozy mysteries, you’ll love Baked Betrayal. Not only does this story feature a thrilling and suspenseful plot, but it also includes delicious recipes for you to try at home. In addition to the mystery, you’ll also learn about the Smoky Mountains, get to know the characters better, and gain insight into their lives as they navigate through the story. The book also includes an Author’s Note and additional reading material so that you can learn even more about the book and its characters. So why wait? Pick up Baked Betrayal today!

Busted in Boston

Here's The Why:

Busted in Boston is a thrilling mystery novel mix of RV travelers and amateur sleuths. Tulia Blake is an independent, strong-willed woman who loves to explore the city of Boston with her RV and boyfriend, Samuel. She follows him to his private investigator office to help out on their most exciting case yet - catching a serial killer on the loose. With gripping suspense, thrilling twists and turns, and great character development, Busted in Boston is a must-read for mystery lovers.

Busted in Boston is a unique and exciting story of murder, suspense, and intrigue. Not only is it a great read for mystery fans, but it also provides readers with an understanding of the complexities of solving a crime. Tulia’s adventures and insights make her an unforgettable character, and the story is sure to keep readers hooked from the first page to the last. If you’re looking for an engaging and thrilling mystery novel, look no further than Busted in Boston.

An Inheritance to Die For

Here's The Why:

An Inheritance to Die For is an exciting and thrilling story of one woman’s journey to uncover the truth of her stepfather’s death. When Lilly inherits Magnolia Manor, she finds more than she expected. The sleepy town is full of secrets and mysteries that Lilly must unravel, and she quickly finds herself in the middle of a dramatic and dangerous situation. With evasive legal assistants, a surly police chief, and a suspicious coroner, Lilly must use her wit and courage to uncover the truth.

An Inheritance to Die For is a thrilling and suspenseful mystery novel that will keep you on the edge of your seat. In this story, Lilly must use her strength and courage to unravel the secrets of Magnolia Manor and uncover the truth of her stepfather’s death. With an intriguing plot, full of twists and turns, this book will keep you guessing until the very end. Whether you’re a fan of mysteries or are looking for an exciting read, An Inheritance to Die For is sure to leave you wanting more.

The Best Cozy Mystery Short Story Just For You!

We hope you’ve enjoyed our list of the top 5 cozy mystery short stories. From thrilling murder mysteries to suspenseful whodunits, these tales are sure to leave you wanting more. Whether you’re looking for a quick read or a few stories to keep you up all night, these tales are sure to entertain.

So if you’re in the mood for a good mystery, why not pick one of these short stories and get ready to solve a crime? Happy reading!

Each product was independently selected by our team, and all opinions in this article are our own. Oh, and FYI — GrayKelly Books may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to buy something. Reviews have been edited for length and clarity. Enjoy finding your next favorite book!

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.