Which Witch?: Conjuring Up Our 5 Most Magical Cozy Mysteries

Witches, spells, and mysteries—oh my! If you're looking for a magical story to get lost in, we've got you covered. Check out the list of our 5 best witchy cozy mystery books to get your cauldron bubbling!

Wynn Kelly

4/7/20236 min read

best witchy cozy mystery
best witchy cozy mystery

Are you looking for a new book to cozy up with? Look no further! We've got the best witchy cozy mysteries that will keep you entertained and spellbound.

Dive into a world of magic and mystery with these witchy cozy mysteries. From magical creatures and supernatural powers to mysterious murders and unsolved cases, these books will have you enthralled from the first page to the last.

You'll be captivated by the unique characters and their captivating stories. Follow along as they solve cases, uncover secrets, and confront the dark forces that lurk in the shadows. With engaging plots and suspenseful twists, these witchy cozy mysteries will keep you on the edge of your seat.

So, if you're looking for a new book to cozy up with, then these best witchy cozy mysteries are sure to do the trick. Get ready to be spellbound as you embark on a journey of magic, mystery, and adventure! So what are you waiting for? Get lost in the pages of these witchy cozy mysteries and have a magical reading experience!

How We Choose The Best Witchy Cozy Mystery Books For You!

With so many different authors and titles available, it can be hard to know which ones are worth your time. The GKB Team’s top picks are based on reader experiences and verified customer reviews on Amazon to find the best cozy books.

We've done all the hard work so that you can easily find and purchase the perfect book for your next reading adventure. From spellbinding stories to captivating characters, we've got just what you need for an enchanting read.

1) Monster Mayhem

Here's The Why:

Step into the world of Luna Thorn and get ready for a wild ride! Luna arrived in Detroit with no memory of who she was or why she was there. But she quickly established herself as a force to be reckoned with on the Detroit magical scene.

She set up a community called the Cathedral to help those who had been displaced from their homes and families, and she is determined to figure out why she’s in Detroit and what she’s supposed to accomplish. But when a body shows up on the grounds of the Cathedral, Luna’s quest kicks into overdrive.

Luna is a force of nature and a master of improvisation. Jesse Wilder is a “by the rules” guy. It’s going to take both of them to solve this case, and even then it will only be the beginning of their tale. If you’re looking for a wild ride with exciting twists and turns, look no further than Monster Mayhem.

2) The Hexhibitionist

Here's The Why:

Fans of cozy mysteries will love The Hexhibitionist. With a body found drained of all fluids, Ofelia knows that something paranormal is afoot and must get to the bottom of it. As if that wasn't enough, the succubus has taken a special interest in Zach Sully, Ofelia's fiancé. Can Ofelia get to the bottom of the mystery and protect the man she loves?

She must use her skills of deduction to unravel the mystery and save Zach from the succubus’s clutches. But she’s not alone. Along the way, she’ll meet some unlikely allies, including a vampire and a werewolf.

With their help, she might just stand a chance against the powerful creature. Get The Hexhibitionist and join Ofelia on her quest to save her fiancé and uncover the truth!

3) The House Witch 3

Here's The Why:

The House Witch 3 is a heart-pounding cozy mystery that follows Finlay Ashowan, a fire witch and servant of King Matthias of Troivack, as he takes on an incredible mission of rescue and espionage.

With the help of his family, friends, and wily kitten familiar, Kraken, Fin must save the life of Annika's brother, Charles, while also fending off Aidan Helmer, his father. The action-packed story is filled with intrigue, danger, and mystery, making it a perfect read for fans of all things witchy.

The characters are well-developed and the plot is full of twists and turns. In addition, the story has a unique blend of magic and suspense that will keep readers entertained until the very end. Get your copy of The House Witch 3 today and immerse yourself in this thrilling adventure!

4) The Witches of Holloway Road

Here's The Why:

The Witches of Holloway Road is an enchanting tale that invites readers to embark on a journey of self-discovery and love with Ursula. Set in a cozy cottage on Holloway Rd, this bewitching story follows Ursula as she unravels a series of strange occurrences.

Ursula must delve into her family’s history, the power of magic, and her own identity to protect everything she cares about. Along the way, she discovers a deeper understanding of the power of witchcraft and the power of love.

With engaging characters and an immersive world, The Witches of Holloway Road is sure to bewitch readers of all ages. Dive into the captivating world of Holloway Road today!

5) Every Trick in the Spellbook

Here's The Why:

Every Trick in the Spellbook is a must-read cozy mystery set in the mystical mountain town of Quincy, California. Professor Astrid Saunders is the beloved professor at Segmimn’s School of Sorcery and must prove her childhood friend-turned-rival, Claudia, was framed when she is charged with murder.

Astrid is in the middle of the drama and will need the help of rag-tag students, a cranky old sorceress, and even her intuitive dog to help her solve the puzzle.

The stakes are high and Astrid can’t afford to lose. She will speak up for Claudia and try to clear her name, even if it means being thrown into the spotlight. This book is filled with mystery, magic, and chemistry between Astrid and the detective assigned to the case, making it a must-read! Get your copy today!

The Best Witchy Cozy Mystery Just For You!

If you're looking for a great witchy cozy mystery to curl up with, you can't go wrong with any of the books on this list. From mysterious spells to thrilling investigations, these stories have it all.

Whether you're looking for a lighthearted read or a more suspenseful one, you're sure to find something that piques your interest in this selection of the best witchy cozy mysteries. So grab a cup of tea and a cozy blanket, and get ready to dive into a magical world of mystery and intrigue!

Each product was independently selected by our team, and all opinions in this article are our own. Oh, and FYI — GrayKelly Books may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page if you decide to buy something. Reviews have been edited for length and clarity. Enjoy finding your next favorite book!

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.